{"$schema": "https://iptc.org/std/ninjs/ninjs-schema_3.2.json", "uri": "urn:newsml:wireva.mib.news:item:ad7bbc3b-b31f-4427-b242-6d5e01189292", "type": "text", "profile": "standard", "version": "1", "versioncreated": "2026-08-21T19:53:37.707486Z", "firstcreated": "2026-07-14T03:01:49.491220Z", "pubstatus": "usable", "urgency": 5, "language": "en", "headline": "CNBC faces backlash over quality-of-life ranking that places red states at bottom", "byline": "Erin Baxter", "located": "United States", "copyrightholder": "Haydamax OÜ", "copyrightnotice": "Wireva / Cronkite", "usageterms": "Subscribers may republish this item in full, including translation and trimming, with the credit “Wireva / Cronkite”. Set rel=canonical to https://cronkite.online/society/cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom/ when publishing on the web.", "description_text": "CNBC's annual quality-of-life ranking, which placed all 10 Republican-led states in the bottom spots, drew criticism from conservatives who argue the criteria reflect liberal bias and ignore population growth trends in those states.", "altids": {"mosaic": "ad7bbc3b-b31f-4427-b242-6d5e01189292", "story": "a32cf771-a1e7-4c39-9321-36683a12b47f", "slug": "cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom"}, "subject": [{"name": "Society", "rel": "direct", "literal": "society", "code": "medtop:14000000", "scheme": "http://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/mediatopic/", "uri": "http://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/mediatopic/14000000"}], "place": [{"name": "United States", "literal": "us", "code": "US", "scheme": "http://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/countrycodes/"}], "person": [], "organisation": [], "genre": [{"name": "Standard story", "literal": "standard"}], "service": [{"name": "Wireva", "literal": "wireva"}], "associations": {"featuremedia": {"uri": "urn:newsml:wireva.mib.news:media:5540c4f3-bc4c-4c63-84c9-4d011b242e2b", "type": "picture", "version": "1", "pubstatus": "usable", "headline": "CNBC survey mocked after ranking all red states as top 10 'worst places to live'", "description_text": "", "copyrightholder": "foxnews.com", "copyrightnotice": "CNBC survey mocked after ranking all red states as top 10 'worst places to live'", "usageterms": "Picture belongs to the source publication: address and terms are delivered, the file is not.", "altids": {"wireva": "5540c4f3-bc4c-4c63-84c9-4d011b242e2b"}, "extra": {"wireva:delivery_mode": "link_only", "wireva:rights": {"licence": "", "licence_url": "", "licence_raw": "Related RSS source", "licence_verified_at": "2026-08-21T19:53:37.718291Z", "attribution_required": true, "attribution_text": "CNBC survey mocked after ranking all red states as top 10 'worst places to live'", "redistribution_allowed": false, "commercial_use_allowed": false, "modifications_allowed": false, "share_alike_required": false}, "wireva:provenance": {"creator": "", "source_name": "foxnews.com", "source_url": "https://www.foxnews.com/culture/cnbc-survey-mocked-ranking-red-states-worst-places-live", "source_page_url": "https://a57.foxnews.com/static.foxnews.com/foxnews.com/content/uploads/2025/11/931/523/lone-star-flag-2025.jpg?ve=1&tl=1", "our_page_url": "https://cronkite.online/society/cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom/"}, "wireva:role": "lead"}, "renditions": {"source": {"href": "https://www.foxnews.com/culture/cnbc-survey-mocked-ranking-red-states-worst-places-live", "mimetype": "image/jpeg"}}}}, "extra": {"wireva:story": {"uri": "urn:newsml:wireva.mib.news:story:a32cf771-a1e7-4c39-9321-36683a12b47f", "slug": "maga-20260714", "status": "closed", "languages": ["en", "ru"], "item_count": 5, "is_breaking": false}, "wireva:rights": {"class": "agency_original", "redistribution_allowed": true, "commercial_use_allowed": true, "modifications_allowed": true, "share_alike_required": false, "attribution_required": true, "attribution_text": "Wireva / Cronkite", "canonical_required": true, "canonical_url": "https://cronkite.online/society/cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom/", "linkback_required": true, "licence": "Wireva subscriber licence", "licence_url": "", "licensor": "Haydamax OÜ", "valid_until": null, "excerpt_max_chars": 0, "decided_by_rule": "agency_original_unassessed_allow", "needs_review": true}, "wireva:provenance": {"production_method": "automated", "ai_stages": {}, "model": "", "human_reviewed": false, "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": null, "editorial_control": true, "editorial_responsibility": "Haydamax OÜ (Wireva)", "factchecked": false, "verification_status": "multi_source", "independent_confirmations": 2, "official_source_used": false, "used_press_release": false, "public_interest": true, "ai_disclosure_required": true, "ai_disclosure_text": "This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OU.", "independence_check": {"status": "not_assessed", "score": 0.0, "checked_at": "2026-08-21T19:53:37.716073Z"}}, "wireva:publication": {"name": "Cronkite", "domain": "cronkite.online", "country": "US", "url": "https://cronkite.online/society/cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom/"}, "wireva:links": {"self": "https://wireva.mib.news/api/v1/items/ad7bbc3b-b31f-4427-b242-6d5e01189292", "html": "https://wireva.mib.news/item/ad7bbc3b-b31f-4427-b242-6d5e01189292/cnbc-faces-backlash-over-quality-of-life-ranking-that-places-red-states-at-bottom/", "story": "https://wireva.mib.news/story/maga-20260714/"}, "wireva:metrics": {"word_count": 731, "char_count": 4789, "reading_time_seconds": 342}}}