Wireva

Stephen A. Smith's comments on White NBA players draw criticism

ESPN's Stephen A. Smith said the Lakers' top three players, all White, are unlikely to get past the second round, drawing pushback and renewing debate over how White athletes are discussed.

ESPN's Stephen A. Smith has drawn fresh criticism after suggesting the Los Angeles Lakers cannot win an NBA championship with their three best players being White. "I do not think that they're getting past the second round," Smith said. "Not a team with its top three players being White dudes." The remark has sparked debate about how race is discussed in sports commentary, and whether White athletes face a double standard when they are criticized on the basis of their race.

Smith has not backed away from the position, even after former NBA players Jay Williams and Kwame Brown, both of whom are Black, publicly challenged him. Smith has also said that the color of the Lakers' Big Three, a group some fans have nicknamed "Snowtime," should be a motivating factor for the "brothers" in the league. Commentator Will Cain has since challenged Smith's claim about "White dudes" in the NBA, calling it racist.

The author of the source piece, writing for OutKick, argues that Smith's comments are not an isolated example. Last month, former NBA player Charlie Villanueva suggested that Dallas Mavericks star Cooper Flagg could not be the face of the league because he is White. "It's a Black league, right?" Villanueva said. "Am I lying? Majority rules." The writer contends that a similar comment about Tiger Woods and golf, a sport long dominated by White players, would have been met with severe backlash, and that no apology could rescue such a commentator's career.

The piece also points to comments from beyond the sports world. In June, former ESPN host Jemele Hill responded to a Threads question about what people would do if they woke up White by saying she would apply for a job with a great salary knowing she had no qualifications. The writer also cites former Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett, who last year said on CNN that "mediocre white boys" who complained about "white tears" could not compete with more qualified minorities.

The writer draws a contrast with cases involving other races. In July, Toronto Tempo coach Sandy Brondello complained to referees that Angel Reese was a "protected species" after a controversial foul call. Brondello, who is Australian, was using a familiar Australian sports phrase for an athlete who receives favorable treatment from officials. Some interpreted the comment as racially offensive, and she issued a public apology specifically acknowledging its impact on Black women. The WNBA suspended her for one game without pay.

The piece also describes the case of Braiden Bell, who was fired as the Portland Trail Blazers' play-by-play announcer in October, less than 12 hours after getting the job. A local TV station had unearthed tweets from 2012, when Bell was 15, including one saying he was not racist but that Asian people angered him. The writer argues that Bell's teenage post drew a harsher consequence than Sarah Jeong received when The New York Times editorial board hired her in 2018 despite past tweets disparaging White people. The Times acknowledged her comments were inappropriate but stood by the hire.

The writer says the comparison is not a call to shield White people from criticism, and that there is nothing wrong with discussing race or making jokes about it. The argument is that the ease with which White people are generalized and dismissed because of their skin color stands out, and that the consequences for remarks about different races are applied unevenly.

Same event, other desks

Story file →