Wireva

Cynthia Erivo leads Prima Facie film adaptation of Suzie Miller's stage play

Cynthia Erivo stars as a successful barrister in the screen version of Suzie Miller's Prima Facie, a sexual assault drama that critics have praised for her performance while divided over whether the adaptation keeps the intimacy of the stage original.

‘Prima Facie’ Review: Cynthia Erivo Brings Conviction, but Not Necessarily a Conviction, to an Impassioned but Clunky Legal Drama
Cynthia Erivo leads Prima Facie film adaptation of Suzie Miller's stage play
Wireva desk · Desk-supplied · rights

Cynthia Erivo gives a committed lead performance in the film adaptation of Suzie Miller's stage play Prima Facie, but critics are divided over whether the screen version holds together as a drama. The film centres on a successful barrister whose professional certainty is tested when she becomes entangled in a sexual assault case, a story that moves from the courtroom into the personal consequences that follow. The material is built on Miller's original stage work, which the film adapts for a cinema audience rather than reproducing as a filmed performance.

Reviews have singled out Erivo as the film's chief asset. The Guardian described her performance as brilliant, and Variety acknowledged the passion the production brings to its subject, although the trade publication found the drama clunky in its construction. The Financial Times took a harsher line, arguing that Erivo cannot rescue what it called a flat adaptation, meaning that even a strong central turn does not compensate for weaknesses in the wider film. The Stage, reviewing the film's nationwide cinema release, described it as subdued, suggesting that the urgency of the original work does not always carry over to the screen. Taken together, these notices point to a consensus on the quality of the lead performance and far less agreement on everything surrounding it.

The central question for critics is what happens when a play built around a single performer and a confined dramatic space is opened out for the cinema. Adapting the work meant expanding its settings and structure, and this widening is where reviewers part ways. Some see the change as a loss of focus, since the stage version relies on the audience sharing the protagonist's experience in a close, unbroken frame. Others regard Erivo's commitment as sufficient to hold the material together, and argue that the larger canvas gives the story room to reach beyond the courtroom. The disagreement is unresolved, and it is likely to shape how audiences approach the film, particularly those who know the play.

The adaptation also marks a wider move of Suzie Miller's work from the theatre to the screen, where a story about consent, reputation and the legal system reaches a far larger public than a single run on stage allows. Miller's play addresses the way the justice system treats complainants, and the film carries that subject into cinemas across the country, where it has been released nationwide. Whether the screen version can sustain the focus and pressure of the original is the question on which the reviews most sharply diverge.

For now, the reception so far suggests that the strength of the lead performance is widely recognised, even as doubts about the film's cohesion persist among the critics who have reviewed it. Readers weighing whether to see the film will find agreement on Erivo and a clear division on the adaptation itself.

Same event, other desks

Story file →