Two South Carolina men have been charged with murder in the road rage shooting death of Scott Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster from North Carolina, after evidence uncovered by his sister undercut the claim that the killing was self-defense. Two former Horry County police officers involved in the investigation now face accusations of official misconduct and obstruction of justice.
Spivey died on Sept. 9, 2023, after a chase on Highway 9 in Horry County ended with his shooting on Camp Swamp Road, about nine miles away. Charles "Weldon" Boyd and Kenneth "Bradley" Williams initially invoked South Carolina's stand your ground law, arguing they were defending themselves from an irrational driver. Both were arrested on Wednesday, more than three years after the shooting.
Brandon Strickland and Paul Vescovi, both former members of the Horry County Police Department, face charges including misconduct in office and obstruction of justice, according to local reports. Strickland, who allegedly spoke with Boyd on the phone after the shooting, was also charged with criminal conspiracy. All four made initial appearances in criminal court Thursday afternoon. At the end of a two-hour hearing, the judge had not ruled on bond requests, according to Myrtle Beach-based WMBF-TV, and a decision was expected later.
According to court documents, Spivey, Boyd and Williams were all armed during the encounter. Spivey eventually pulled over, got out of his vehicle and shouted at the two men to stop following him. The pursuers allegedly opened fire and killed him, in what his sister's attorney described in a wrongful death lawsuit as "a hail of gunfire."
The turn in the case came from Spivey's sister, Jennifer Spivey Foley, who uncovered recordings from Boyd's phone that were buried in the police case file and had never been made public or factored into the investigation. The Wall Street Journal published them last year, drawing national attention to the case. Foley attended Thursday's hearing and asked the judge to deny bond for Boyd and Williams and to order a mental health evaluation for Boyd.
According to court documents in the family's wrongful death case, the recordings indicate Boyd told a 911 dispatcher that Spivey was "trying to get away" yet was prepared for a shootout. "If I see the gun again, I'm going to take the motherf----- down," Boyd allegedly told the dispatcher, according to the civil complaint filed in 2024. Boyd remained on the line until the shooting took place, the lawsuit says. Later, according to the Journal's report, he allegedly called a friend who was Horry County's deputy police chief at the time.
Defense filings in the civil case allege that Spivey had pointed a pistol at Williams' head and ran Boyd's truck off the road at the start of the encounter. In a 911 call, a man identified as Boyd told the dispatcher that the other driver shot first. Circuit Court Judge Eugene Griffith, who is overseeing the family's civil suit against Boyd and Williams, ruled in that case that Boyd's secretly recorded phone calls showed he was seeking law enforcement help and trying to avoid responsibility.
Boyd and Williams' lawyers had filed for a stay of proceedings in the civil case on Nov. 5, citing a pending grand jury inquiry, according to court records. Within days, their clients were indicted. The criminal case is being handled by a special prosecutor after local prosecutors declined to file criminal charges.
Mark Tinsley, the attorney representing Spivey's family, said in a statement posted to Facebook that the family had long believed the death was not justified. "For over three years, Scott Spivey's family has fought for something that should never have required a fight, the truth about how and why Scott was killed," he wrote. He added that the tragedy was also that the family had to fight the very system that was supposed to investigate the death in order to reach the truth.
Spivey's mother, Deborah Spivey, told "The Will Cain Show" last year that she did not accept the stand your ground claim, pointing to the allegation that her son had been followed for almost 10 miles before the fatal confrontation. "It does not fit the 'stand your ground' [law], when someone tries to de-escalate, tries to leave the scene," she said. "It doesn't fit that."