Farmers across several states are pressing the Trump administration to give them more control over gray wolves, which they say are killing livestock and threatening their livelihoods. The Interior Department must decide by Dec. 3 whether gray wolves and Mexican wolves have met recovery criteria under the Endangered Species Act, a finding that would trigger the process of removing or reducing federal protections.
Shayne Isane, a Minnesota farmer who has worked his land for nearly four decades, said he has lost several calves to wolves roaming his property at night. He said one of his largest losses came when three young calves were killed in a single night. Isane, who keeps nearly 300 cattle, described the threat in stark terms. "We can walk right outside of our door and hear the howling of these timber wolves, and it'll send shivers down your spine because you have seen what they can do, and they're the top-of-the-line predator," he told Fox News Digital.
Isane said the law leaves him with few options. "Even if we see them attacking our livestock, we can't shoot or try to help out our animals," he said, adding that lethal action is permitted only in cases involving a threat to human life. He said wolves often drag away or dispose of carcasses, which makes it difficult to confirm an attack to state investigators. In Minnesota, a farmer must have the carcass in order to confirm a suspected wolf attack and report the loss within 48 hours to receive reimbursement. Isane said each lost animal can cost about $3,000, which he said affects his bottom line.
Beyond outright losses, Isane said the constant presence of wolves stresses the herd. He said cattle are harassed, lose weight and remain on edge, which affects their overall health. He added that deterrent methods recommended by the state have not worked because wolves are able to outsmart them. "They just don't work," he said.
The Minnesota Department of Agriculture said its program provides 100 percent reimbursement of verified losses at full market value and pointed to its Wolf Livestock Depredation Grant. The department said that while it can help farmers with prevention and losses, wolf management does not fall under its work. Isane argued that environmentalists are not seeing the full picture, saying the wolf population has grown out of control. He recalled that in the first 30 years of his life he hardly saw a timber wolf, while in the last 25 years he has seen multiple wolves, perhaps 50 to 100.
The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources estimates there were about 2,400 gray wolves in the state in 2026, with no statistically significant change from the previous year. A department spokesperson said the agency is confident in its research and that the estimates indicate a stable population, not one of unconstrained or rapid growth.
The White House has framed the issue as one of agricultural policy. Deputy press secretary Taylor Rogers said the previous administration's environmental policies left ranchers defenseless as predators killed their livestock. Rogers said the national cattle herd reached a 75-year low, driving up prices for consumers, and that President Trump is reversing those policies to fight for ranchers.
Shawn Regan, editor of C3 Journal and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, argued that states can manage recovered wolf populations effectively without the species remaining listed under the Endangered Species Act. He said the law is not the best tool for managing recovered populations over the long term, noting that it includes a delisting process to allow transition to state management.
Delisting gray wolves has long been part of Trump's agenda. During his first term, the administration removed federal protections for the species across most states. The measure could affect states including Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, California and Colorado. Environmental groups, represented by the law group Earthjustice, have challenged earlier moves to strip protections, and the current decision will test how the administration balances livestock losses against the species' recovery status.