A New York City woman says a prominent LGBTQ+ activist struck her during a counter-protest outside Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan, an incident she has reported to the New York Police Department. Christiane Torello alleges that Jay Walker, president of the advocacy group Gays Against Guns and the 2026 NYC Pride Grand Marshal, hit her chest with his elbow during the demonstration on Nov. 5. Neither the NYPD nor Walker's group has publicly commented on the allegation.
Torello, who opposes gender-transition treatments for minors, was protesting at the hospital in support of its decision to stop such care. Mount Sinai ended gender-affirming care for minors in September, a move that followed a Department of Justice investigation into youth gender transition procedures. Torello came to the site to back that decision, and the protest brought opposing demonstrators to the same location, where the two groups confronted one another.
Torello described Walker, whom she said is about 6 feet 5 inches tall, as having likely aimed for her face before the blow landed on her chest. She said the confrontation was heated on both sides, and that video she recorded shows her and Walker yelling and cursing at each other. That recording is part of the material she has provided to investigators, according to her account, and it captures the exchange that preceded the alleged contact.
Torello said she does not expect charges to be filed in the matter. She also described an earlier incident at a protest in which she says she was assaulted, and said police did not address that complaint either. That history is the basis for her doubts about the current report, and it is one reason she has pressed the case publicly rather than relying on a police response alone. It remains unclear whether police plan to make any arrests in connection with the November incident.
The episode unfolds against a broader dispute over the treatment of transgender minors and the demonstrations that have followed hospital policy changes. Mount Sinai's September decision placed the hospital at the center of a national debate, with supporters of the change and opponents of it both bringing their arguments to its front entrance. Torello's account shows how those confrontations can move from argument to physical contact, a development that has now become a matter for the NYPD to review.
Walker, as president of Gays Against Guns, has been a visible figure in New York LGBTQ+ politics, and his designation as 2026 NYC Pride Grand Marshal places him in a prominent public role. Neither Walker nor his organization has responded to the allegation in public, and the NYPD has not said whether the complaint has been logged for investigation or what steps, if any, will follow. The absence of a public response from either side leaves Torello's account as the only detailed version of events available at this stage.