A growing number of older Americans are buying Tesla vehicles and Cybertrucks in part because of the company’s Full Self-Driving system, a feature that safety experts say is being misunderstood by some of the drivers who rely on it most. Among them is a retired physician in his 90s who uses the software, and a neighbor in a North Carolina retirement community whose experience has drawn attention to the issue.
The system, marketed as Full Self-Driving (Supervised), is classified as Level 2 driver assistance. Tesla’s own owner’s manual states that the driver must remain attentive and be ready to take over at all times. Despite that requirement, some seniors appear to be buying the vehicles because they are losing the ability to drive safely on their own, including because of failing eyesight. Tesla North America promoted the purchase of a Cybertruck by a 71-year-old on its official X account, a post that highlighted how the product is being presented to older buyers.
The concern is heightened by the broader data on older drivers. Drivers in their 60s are less likely than the general public to be involved in fatal crashes, but drivers over 85 are significantly more prone to them. Roughly three in 10 Americans with dementia still drive, a fact that complicates the question of who should be behind the wheel. Research from Columbia has linked giving up driving to faster cognitive and physical decline, which adds a personal dimension to the decision many families face.
Safety researchers have pointed out that Level 2 systems are convenience features rather than safety systems, according to the Insurance Institute. The institute and other experts note that when such systems require a driver to intervene, reaction times can be slower. Tesla claims that cars using Full Self-Driving crash less often, but those claims have not been independently validated, and data on crashes involving older drivers using the system is scarce. In one case, a 91-year-old was involved in a crash at a Trader Joe’s, but it is unclear whether Full Self-Driving was in use.
The debate has also been fueled by Tesla’s marketing and by posts from Elon Musk. A Tesla marketing video showed a driver making espresso while the system was engaged, and California required the company to add “(Supervised)” to the product’s name. Musk reshared videos of a 98-year-old named Larry and a 93-year-old named Lois; the Larry video contradicts the company’s manual, and a Johns Hopkins expert questioned the safety of the Lois footage. Europe, for its part, required Tesla to rename the system “Full Assisted Driving.”
Senator Ed Markey has vowed to hold Musk and Tesla accountable. The $99-per-month subscription cost adds to the financial commitment for buyers, and only robotaxi services such as Waymo and Zoox currently offer consumer autonomous trips. For families and older drivers, the AARP’s free “We Need to Talk” webinar is one of the organization’s leading driver-safety resources. An expert’s guidance on the matter is blunt: if you can’t drive yourself, don’t drive with Full Self-Driving.