U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee is publicly disputing Vice President JD Vance’s explanation for Republicans’ heavy losses in the midterm elections, arguing that Israel was not a factor in the outcome. In an exclusive interview with The Press Service of Israel published Tuesday, Huckabee rejected the idea that the relationship with Israel was responsible for the party’s defeat and instead pointed to economic concerns, voter apathy and a failure to energize Republican voters. "Israel was not the reason the elections went wrong for Republicans last week," Huckabee told TPS-IL.
The disagreement follows a post by Vance on X on Nov. 4 in which he cited polling to argue that voters who backed the Trump-Vance ticket in 2024 had turned against Republicans over four key issues: ending the war with Iran, addressing inflation and the cost of living, putting America first, and changing the U.S. relationship with Israel. "The reason we lost is the war," Vance wrote, arguing that the party needed to acknowledge the political consequences of the conflict. Huckabee, a former Arkansas governor and longtime Evangelical leader, offered a competing explanation, saying that the Republican Party had not given its own supporters a compelling reason to turn out. "To say that Israel was on the minds of most people is, I think, ludicrous," he said.
A spokesperson for Vance responded to Huckabee’s comments in a statement to Fox News Digital. "The Vice President did not blame Jews for the Republican Party’s losses in the midterms," the spokesperson said. "The Vice President has forcefully condemned antisemitism on countless occasions, and he will continue to do so." Vance himself has acknowledged that the war may have influenced voters’ perceptions, particularly as families struggled with higher fuel and food costs. He said the impact came less from the war itself than from media coverage that linked the conflict to economic hardship.
Huckabee maintained that economic issues were the central factor. He acknowledged that the war in Iran "may have contributed to prices, but it wasn’t the only thing. There were a lot of factors involved." He cited exit polling showing that white evangelical Christians made up 17 percent of voters in the 2026 midterms, compared with 23 percent in 2024. That figure describes the share of the electorate rather than the portion of evangelicals who voted, but Huckabee used it to argue that turnout among this bloc was a decisive weakness. "There is no bloc of voters that is more critical to a Republican victory than Evangelical voters in the United States," he said. "They represent 80 million people. If they go vote in mass numbers, Republicans win, if they stay home, Republicans lose."
Huckabee also argued that Republicans, despite controlling the White House, the Senate and the House, had not delivered enough legislative accomplishments to motivate their base. "The real reason was that Republicans did not give even Republicans a good reason to go vote for them," he said. "The Democrats were excited. They went and voted in mass numbers, and they voted with enthusiasm. Enthusiasm wins elections; apathy does not." He added that it was unfortunate Israel had been cited as a major reason for the outcome, because it did not appear to be as credible an explanation as low turnout from the Republican base.
The dispute comes as the administration continues to weigh its approach to Iran. Huckabee warned that additional U.S. military action remains possible if Tehran refuses to abandon its nuclear ambitions, while expressing hope that diplomacy or economic pressure could resolve the matter. "It’s very possible that we will end up there, because if the Iranians do not understand what the president has made very clear, at least for the U.S. position, and that is they can’t have a nuclear weapon," he said. He added that Secretary of State Marco Rubio had recently said the military option remains on the table. Huckabee also said that Trump had acknowledged the war may have been a factor in the midterm losses but had maintained that he would do it all over again. The ambassador defended that stance, arguing that the decision was driven by threats to American national security rather than political calculation.