Wireva

Trump signals openness to immigration deal on legal status after midterm losses

Trump told 60 Minutes he would work on a deal on legal status for immigrants, then ruled out amnesty and said policy is unchanged, while experts split sharply over the fallout.

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

President Donald Trump said he would «work on a deal» on the legal status of immigrants living in the United States illegally, a remark made in a “60 Minutes” interview that aired days after Republicans suffered losses in the midterm elections. The comments drew immediate attention because they touch one of the most contested issues in American politics, though Trump has since ruled out amnesty and said his immigration policy has not changed. No specific proposal has been outlined.

The response from immigration analysts has been sharply divided. Mark Krikorian of the Center for Immigration Studies, a group that favors tighter limits on immigration, argued that any form of legal status for people who entered or remained in the country unlawfully would undercut the rule of law. He also said such a move would be unfair to visa overstayers who left the country on time. Krikorian was pessimistic about the prospects for any deal, calling the likelihood close to zero, and said Democrats are unlikely to accept immigration restrictions in exchange for legalization.

Jessica Collins of the George W. Bush Presidential Center took a different view, arguing that current laws are unworkable. She pointed to a gap between labor demand in the American economy and a legal immigration system that restricts the flow of workers. Collins noted that past legalization bills generally required applicants to pay back taxes, pass background checks and pay fines, and she cited research indicating that the assimilation rates of today's unauthorized immigrants are similar to those of earlier immigrant generations. She added that work authorization is seen as speeding assimilation.

Camarota, the research director at the Center for Immigration Studies, raised concerns about scale, warning that large numbers of newly legalized immigrants could overwhelm the assimilation process. He also estimated that illegal-immigrant households receive roughly $50 billion a year in benefits, much of it flowing through the eligibility of U.S.-born children, while the less-educated population in that group pays limited taxes. Collins countered with a 2013 Congressional Budget Office estimate that a comprehensive reform bill, known as S. 744, would reduce the federal deficit by about $158 billion over ten years.

The debate has also reached the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, known as DACA. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin floated the idea of permanent status for DACA recipients. Krikorian warned that green cards issued to them could later enable those recipients to sponsor their parents without numerical caps, a consequence he described as a major risk.

The White House has maintained that policy is unchanged and that the southern border is «the most secure in history,» and a spokeswoman urged Democrats to cooperate on border security. The Department of Homeland Security did not respond to a request for comment on the proposals. For now, the president's remarks have opened a broader argument over whether a legal-status compromise is possible, and what it would cost and change if pursued.

Same event, other desks

Story file →