A federal judge in Massachusetts has struck down a Department of Homeland Security rule that would have ended the "duration of status" system for foreign students and capped their stays at four years, regardless of how long their academic programs lasted. The ruling, issued by U.S. District Judge Dennis Saylor of the Massachusetts District Court, found that the policy was arbitrary and that its costs and benefits had not been properly weighed. Saylor was appointed to the bench by President George W. Bush.
The rule, issued in July, applied to students holding F and J visas, the categories used for academic and exchange programs. Under the existing system, students remain in the country for the length of their programs. The proposed four-year limit would have forced many students to seek extensions or leave before completing their studies. Saylor concluded that the department's rationale did not hold up. He found the fraud and security justifications unconvincing, and he said the rule conflicted with Congress's intent to encourage students to study in the United States. The existing definition of duration of status remains in effect.
Education groups challenged the rule in August, arguing that it would deter prospective students and burden colleges that depend on them. The Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education, one of the plaintiffs, warned that the policy would worsen falling enrollment and place added strain on campuses. Its president said the rule threatened real harm to students and to the institutions that host them. The Institute of International Education has reported that new international enrollment this fall fell 15 percent, a decline the plaintiffs argued the rule would deepen.
The Department of Homeland Security defended the policy. Officials argued that stricter visa rules curb fraud and protect American workers, and they contended that students were remaining in the country indefinitely and taking advantage of the openness of the U.S. system. Saylor did not accept that reasoning as a basis for the change, and the decision leaves the department without the four-year cap it had sought to impose.
The case is one of several in which the administration's immigration policies have run into legal resistance. The administration has pressed on skilled foreign workers as well as on illegal immigration, and federal courts have blocked a $100,000 fee for employers hiring workers under the H-1B visa program. For colleges, which rely on international students for tuition revenue and research capacity, the student visa ruling removes immediate uncertainty about how long students can remain while completing their degrees, though the broader debate over the rule's stated goals continues.