Former Senator Sam Brownback has said his 2001 vote to grant China permanent normal trade relations was the worst of his 14 years in the Senate, and he is now calling on Washington to reverse that decision. In an opinion piece, Brownback argues that the United States wrongly expected expanded trade to liberalize the communist government in Beijing, and he proposes ending the arrangement altogether.
Brownback was one of 83 senators who supported the measure, which gave China access to the trade treatment normally extended to close allies such as Britain and Israel. China joined the World Trade Organization in December 2001, roughly one year after the grant. In his account, the vote reflected a hope that economic integration would bring political openness, a hope he now says did not materialize.
In his critique, Brownback points to China's treatment of Uyghurs, Tibetans and Falun Gong practitioners. He also argues that Beijing leads an authoritarian alliance, is expanding its nuclear arsenal, and now operates a naval fleet that rivals or exceeds the United States in number of vessels. He says that roughly 100 million Christians in China face restrictions on their faith.
To make his case, Brownback draws a comparison with the Soviet Union, which never received favored trade status from the United States. He recalls that cutting Soviet access to American markets during the Reagan administration weakened Moscow's ability to finance its war effort. Applying the same logic, he proposes what he calls a "Helsinki Accord 2.0," which would link access to American markets to improvements in human rights. He acknowledges that China's economy would suffer if it lost American markets.
It remains unclear whether Brownback's proposal to end permanent normal trade relations with China would win support in Congress. It is also unknown how Beijing would respond to a demand that market access be tied to human rights conditions.
Brownback's essay comes as lawmakers are scrutinizing the government's handling of technology exports to China. Senator Maria Cantwell has criticized Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick in a letter, arguing that the Commerce Department failed to enforce restrictions on Nvidia artificial intelligence chips. Cantwell alleges that advanced AI chips reached China-linked companies despite congressional authority to limit such transfers. She says these lapses undermine national security and weaken America's advantage in AI technology.