Andy Burnham has said Brexit has not worked for the United Kingdom and that Britain needs a closer relationship with the European Union, ahead of a reset summit with EU leaders in Brussels on 20 November.
The prime minister is seeking what he describes as a new approach with the bloc. The Friday summit is expected to focus on securing agreements on food, energy and youth mobility, which the government intends to present as arrangements that benefit both sides. The specific terms of any of these deals have not yet been made public.
Burnham will rule out a number of options that have been debated in the Brexit aftermath. These include rejoining the single market, joining a customs union and restoring freedom of movement. Such options would breach Labour's election manifesto, which is why they are off the table for the government's negotiations.
The positions are informed in part by a 170-page report from the Growth Commission, chaired by Shanker Singham. The report estimates that rejoining the EU could leave households £6,500 worse off over a decade. It puts the cost of customs union membership at £2,300 per household and the cost of full membership of the single market for goods at £3,210 per family. It also estimates that a full EU rejoin could cost nearly £200 billion by 2036. By contrast, the commission argues that improving the existing Trade and Cooperation Agreement could add more than £13,000 to household income over the same period.
Energy and climate minister Ed Miliband has acknowledged that trade-offs and costs exist in any closer arrangement with the EU and said the government will set out its options after the summit. He said most voters feel the current Brexit deal is not working. Foreign Minister Stephen Doughty has said the immediate focus is on removing red tape from the existing agreement rather than on wholesale change.
Opposition voices have pushed back. Reform UK's Richard Tice opposes rejoining the EU and points to what he describes as weak economies within the bloc. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has attacked Labour's stance on the Rwanda migration plan, a separate issue that the government has been asked to address alongside its European agenda.
It remains unsettled which trade-offs Burnham will ultimately accept. The outcome of the Brussels meeting will shape what kind of relationship with the EU the government pursues in the months ahead.