Wireva

Video game design offers businesses lessons in loyalty beyond gamification

A former video game executive argues that companies should copy what makes games engaging, such as social connection and personal mastery, rather than relying on points and leaderboards.

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

Businesses have spent years trying to copy the appeal of video games by adding points, badges and leaderboards to their products. According to a former video game executive, that approach misses what actually keeps players coming back. The real lesson, he argues, lies in the deeper psychological drivers that game designers have studied for decades, and those drivers apply well beyond entertainment.

The author, who started his career in video games as a marketing chief, recalls how the idea took shape in the early 2000s. He was a midcareer video game executive when he was asked to meet a young online bookstore founder in Seattle, Jeff Bezos. Instead of pitching a generic plan, he sketched a customer loyalty program modeled on the strategy that had turned the Madden NFL series into a franchise that players return to year after year. He wrote the concept on a one-page document headlined with a single name: Amazon Prime. Bezos laughed, but he listened and read the page.

The executive says the success of Prime illustrated a broader point. Once a company understands how games tap into intrinsic motivation, it can apply that thinking to nearly any consumer business. Over time, he says he brought these lessons to companies in entertainment, finance, education and health. He cites examples including Spotify, the mortgage lender Better Mortgage, the learning platforms Coursera and Duolingo, and the fitness app MyFitnessPal. He once called this practice video gamification, but he has since stopped using the term, because the word has taken on a negative meaning.

That reputation, he argues, is deserved in part. Many product teams that added points and leaderboards in the 2010s reported that these features made little difference to retention metrics. Some users also began to see gamification as a tool for manipulating their time and attention. He contends that the failure came from a basic misunderstanding of how good games work. Successful games, he says, rarely depend on competition to motivate players. Cooperation tends to play a larger role.

He ranks the top reasons players return to a game as social connection, personal mastery and productivity, in that order. Many business leaders assume that money and rankings are the strongest motivators, but he says the video game industry has long found that social relationships and a sense of self-improvement matter more. He points to the early days of the Facebook game Farmville, developed by Zynga. Notifications inviting friends to play cooperatively drew 30 times the clicks of competitive, brag-based notifications. In his account, a two-way social interaction is the strongest predictor of whether someone returns the next day.

Personal mastery works in a similar way. Mechanics such as experience points and level-ups give people a clear framework for tracking their own progress, which creates a sense of momentum with each session. In well-designed games, scores matter most as a measure of individual growth rather than as a ranking against other people. Productivity measures such as time saved and money earned still matter, he notes, but they are most powerful when they align with social and personal goals.

He points to LinkedIn's Endorsements feature as an example of cooperative design outside gaming. The feature invites users to publicly vouch for colleagues, which strengthens professional relationships and gives people a reason to return to the platform even when they are not job hunting. Amazon Prime, in his view, succeeds for a similar reason. It offers free and fast shipping, which delivers a clear productivity benefit by saving time, and personalized profiles help customers form identities as shoppers. He adds that how often members use their benefits is one of the strongest predictors of whether they renew. Pushing members to buy things they would not otherwise purchase, however, could undermine long-term loyalty.

For that reason, Amazon treats Prime as a long-running game franchise, steadily improving the experience and adding benefits such as Prime Video, Amazon Music and prescription savings. The broader message for businesses, as the executive frames it, is that durable engagement comes from giving people more of what they already want, not from attaching game-like mechanics to a product.