A discussion thread on the movie forum Reddit has revived an old Hollywood question: have adults in the industry ever openly criticized a child actor's ability or suitability for a role? The post, which appeared in the r/movies community, does not name a specific child performer. Instead, it asks other users to point to documented cases in which actors or filmmakers spoke against a young performer's talent or fit for a part.
To illustrate the kind of behavior it has in mind, the original poster points to several well-known episodes involving adult stars and directors. The post cites Marlon Brando objecting to the casting of Burt Reynolds in »Deliverance«, and Michael Douglas reportedly resisting the casting of Sharon Stone in »Basic Instinct«. It also mentions director Jim Gillespie antagonizing Freddie Prinze Jr. on the set of »I Know What You Did Last Summer«. None of these examples involves a child actor. The poster explicitly sets aside Gene Wilder's reported dislike of Paris Themmen on »Willy Wonka«, which is the one case that would have fit the question more closely, and therefore does not count it as an example.
The thread is framed as a question rather than a reported account, and it does not present confirmed examples of an adult publicly disparaging a child actor's talent. The examples offered concern adult performers and directors who were reportedly unhappy with casting decisions or working relationships, not statements aimed at children. Because the post itself names no child performer and supplies no confirmed quotations from adults about a young actor, the central question remains unanswered in the material available.
The lack of verified cases is what gives the thread its open-ended character. Participants are being asked to supply their own recollections, and any answer will depend on whether a remark was made on the record or only reported secondhand. Without that distinction, the discussion stays at the level of anecdote rather than documented record.
The additional material gathered alongside the thread does not bear on the question. One unrelated item covers coverage of the score for Rockstar's upcoming game »Grand Theft Auto VI«, and another covers Arab women filmmakers at the Cairo Film Festival. Neither addresses child actor casting or any dispute over a young performer's ability, so they add no detail to the matter raised in the thread.