Negotiators at this year's U.N. climate summit in Turkey were fighting over how to address global warming as the two-week meeting, known as COP31, neared its scheduled close on Friday. Activists and some country leaders erupted after the term “fossil fuels” was left out of the draft final agreement. Negotiators who pulled an all-nighter from Thursday into Friday said they expected the talks to go into overtime on Saturday.
Climate summits typically end with a final text describing how the world will respond to climate change. Such agreements, often adopted by nearly 200 nations, remain voluntary and non-binding. Past COPs have struggled to agree on how to move away from coal, oil and gas, the fuels that warm the planet, heat the oceans and worsen air quality. Climate change has also intensified several disasters this year, including deadly heat waves in Europe and devastating flooding in Nepal.
Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, warned that if fossil fuels do not appear in the final agreement, the summit risks being remembered as the “worst COP ever.” In a rare move, Panama said it would formally object if the final agreement fails to add climate finance, cap oil production and acknowledge that goals are failing, among other demands. Panama's Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said the talks were being held hostage by a “petroleum mafia” and needed reform. “The COPs have become an exercise in hypocrisy and futility,” he said. “What we have here is a contest to see who speaks the most, who blows the most hot air.”
Before the summit, the United Nations said the world was dangerously close to missing its long-standing goal of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial temperatures. At a Friday event, where attendees chanted and held signs reading “SHAME!”, Tasneem Essop, executive director of Climate Action Network International, said there was “nothing on the table that protects people, or addresses the priorities of the Global South.”
One of the main proposals at COP31 is an electrification goal to raise the share of electricity in total global energy consumption from roughly 21 percent today to 35 percent by 2035. However, the final draft does not specify that this should be met with renewable sources such as solar and wind, leaving room for fossil fuel power plants to count toward the electrification push. Ghiwa Nakat, executive director of Greenpeace in the Middle East and North Africa, said that “at a time when the climate crisis demands decisive action, weakening commitments on fossil fuel phase-out risks undermining progress.”
The debate builds on a recent history of commitments. The U.N. has hosted climate talks for more than 30 years, but nations first acknowledged in 2021, at COP26 in Glasgow, Scotland, that fossil fuels contribute to climate change. Two years later, at COP28 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, countries explicitly called for a transition away from fossil fuels for the first time. Turkey and Australia, the co-hosts of COP31, are now being widely criticized for removing fossil fuels from the draft text.
Turkey's Minister of Environment Murat Kurum, who is overseeing the summit in the Turkish resort town of Antalya, said, “We are not here to discuss decisions at previous COPs.” He argued that the electrification push implies a transition away from fossil fuels. Adow responded that “removing those words from a document will not remove the pollution from the atmosphere,” adding that the negotiations had become detached from what is needed outside the conference center.
Finance is another sticking point. Leaders from vulnerable nations, which are mostly poorer and emit relatively few greenhouse gases but are heavily affected by climate change, say wealthy countries are not delivering funds previously agreed upon. They argue that U.N. funding for adapting to climate risks, managing impacts and building clean energy infrastructure falls short of what the U.N. says they need. The draft calls for tripling the money for adaptation but does not specify an amount. An earlier version stated that at least $120 billion would be needed annually.
Many of the world's biggest polluters did not take part directly in this year's talks, including the United States, the world's largest economy and a major emitter. Vulnerable countries want funding mainly from richer nations such as the U.S., and that is difficult to pursue without American officials at the table. A recent report from the nonprofit Climate Action Tracker found that efforts to slow global warming have essentially stalled over the past five years.
“Disappointment is rife,” said Iskander Erzini Vernoit, an adviser to African negotiators in Turkey. “Hope is not lost, but absent a course correction, we are headed toward a low-ambition set of outcomes at COP31.” The next climate summit is scheduled for November 2027 in Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia.