New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced at an early Monday news briefing that he is dissolving the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, a unit that has drawn criticism for its handling of left-wing protests. The move reshapes how the city's police department deals with demonstrations, and it has already drawn opposition from police unions.
Under the plan, the Strategic Response Group will be replaced by an unarmed Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division that will not have arrest authority. The department will also create a First Amendment Support Team of 30 uniformed officers trained in de-escalation, along with a Patrol Support Division made up mostly of patrol officers who have received crowd-control training. Counterterrorism responsibilities will move to the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. The changes are slated to take effect by spring 2027.
Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch has said the city's public safety capacity will be preserved under the new structure. Critics of the decision, including police unions, argue that the unit's removal weakens the city's defenses. Their central objection is that unarmed teams cannot stop bombers. Opponents say the Strategic Response Group is also central to the city's responses to terror attacks and mass-casualty incidents, not only to protests, which is why they see its dissolution as a gap in preparedness.
The unit's record includes several high-profile security responses. Earlier this year, a bombing attempt near Gracie Mansion, the mayor's official residence, occurred during dueling demonstrations. Two men allegedly inspired by ISIS were charged in that case, though the bombs did not detonate. Last year, a mass shooting took place at an office building on Park Avenue that houses the headquarters of the NFL, and the Strategic Response Group helped search the building floor by floor.
Beyond emergencies, the unit has regularly staffed parades, the New Year's Eve ball drop in Times Square, and other large public events. Former FBI official James Gagliano has described the unit as a deterrent and a senior, SWAT-like force, a characterization that frames the debate over whether its replacement can fill the same role. The overhaul therefore turns on a basic question for the department: whether new teams focused on de-escalation can absorb duties that have, until now, been handled by an armed unit trained for the most serious scenarios.
The decision is also a test of how the new administration balances civil liberties with security. Supporters of the overhaul argue that the department's approach to protests needs to change, and the First Amendment Support Team is designed to put de-escalation at the center of demonstration policing. Opponents counter that the replacement structure lacks the authority and firepower of the unit it replaces, leaving the city to rely on newly created teams during periods of heightened risk. Commissioner Tisch's assurance that public safety capacity will be preserved has not, so far, quieted those concerns.