Wireva

Government spending and Fed rate moves are slowing economic growth, Forbes columnist argues

A Forbes opinion piece by John Tamny contends that government spending and Federal Reserve interest-rate changes restrain growth because production, not government activity, drives demand.

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

Government spending and Federal Reserve interest-rate changes are holding back economic growth, according to a Forbes opinion column by John Tamny published in November 2026. Tamny argues that the economy is driven by production, and that government, which he says produces nothing itself, diverts resources away from the private sector that actually creates the goods and services people buy.

The central claim rests on the idea that demand follows production. In Tamny's view, when public spending rises, it alters patterns of consumption and investment rather than adding new output. Resources that would otherwise flow to businesses and households are redirected through government budgets, and that redirection, he contends, distorts the decisions that would otherwise shape how the economy grows. The logic runs in a single direction: output comes first, and spending follows from the wealth that productive activity generates.

Tamny applies the same reasoning to the Federal Reserve. He argues that adjustments to interest rates interfere with the price signals that guide investment and spending, and that this interference weighs on growth rather than supporting it. The column frames both government outlays and monetary policy as forces that act on the economy from outside the productive process, substituting administrative judgment for the decisions of individual savers, borrowers and entrepreneurs.

The distinction Tamny draws is between activity that creates value and activity that moves value from one place to another. Under his framework, a dollar spent by a government agency is a dollar removed from a private use, and the economy must then reorganize around the government's choices. Rate changes operate on the same logic through the cost of money, which he treats as a signal that the market should set rather than a central bank.

The piece is an opinion column, and its argument is a matter of economic interpretation rather than a reported finding. The excerpt available for this report does not include specific figures, data series, named studies, or comparisons with particular periods or countries, so the column's conclusions are presented as the author's position. Readers weighing the debate over fiscal and monetary policy will find the case rests on the principle that government spending and rate decisions substitute political and administrative judgment for market-driven production.

The argument reflects a long-running position among free-market commentators that public spending and central bank intervention can crowd out private activity. Economists who favor active fiscal or monetary policy typically contend that such measures can offset downturns and support employment, a counterpoint that the column does not address in the material available here. The debate therefore centers on whether the drag from government and the Fed outweighs their stabilizing effects, a question that depends on empirical evidence beyond what this single column provides.