Pod Save America co-host and Crooked Media cofounder Jon Favreau argues that Democrats' strong showing in the midterm elections reflects everyday economic pressure more than the messaging of the media. In a conversation with The Verge's Nilay Patel on the Decoder podcast, Favreau said voters judged the party in power on whether life had become more affordable, and found it wanting.
The interview opened with a broader question: why the outcome came now, after a wave of tech billionaires had moved to reshape the information ecosystem. Patel pointed to Elon Musk's purchase of Twitter and its rebranding as X, Mark Zuckerberg's rapprochement with Donald Trump as Meta scaled back its content moderation, the Ellison family's stakes in TikTok, and the changes at CBS News and the possible takeover of CNN. Favreau responded that Americans, despite that consolidation of media ownership, still saw through it. He framed the midterms as a repudiation of a government that had promised to bring inflation down and make life more affordable, and did not deliver.
Favreau was careful not to reduce politics to a single issue, though he acknowledged that the simple explanation was the most persuasive. He said that in recent elections, voters have elected a party and then judged it by whether prices fell and whether they could afford gas, groceries and housing. Lived experience, he argued, tends to outweigh the messages voters receive from political media. He noted that the same dynamic has affected Democrats, citing the phrase Defund the Police as an example of a message that spiraled out of control and may have cost the party votes. The lesson, in his view, is that messaging has limits when material conditions are poor, and that this applies to whoever holds the White House.
The conversation also turned to Crooked itself, which Patel described as a fascinating business. Conservative media have long built a direct-to-consumer pipeline, from talk radio onward, and Favreau and his cofounders have sought to create a comparable model for liberal creators. According to Favreau, the company hired its first chief executive a few years ago, now offers more than a dozen original shows, and employs around 100 people across live events and political advocacy. He said its subscription business has passed 65,000 members.
Patel said the discussion would cover online distribution, the platform power of YouTube, and the tension between running a business that must make money and a newsroom with a political mission and a strong point of view. Artificial intelligence was also on the agenda. Favreau has turned his own podcast Offline into something close to an AI policy show this year and has views on how Congress should approach the issue. The interview was lightly edited for length and clarity.