Wireva

BMW's electric M3 uses four motors to brake and steer with near-instant response

BMW's new all-electric M3 integrates its braking, stability and torque-vectoring systems into a single controller, delivering a level of responsiveness that the writer says none of the cars he has driven can match.

BMW's new electric M3 may be the most technically ambitious performance saloon the company has built, and its engineering goes well beyond headline acceleration figures. The car's four-motor layout removes much of the hydraulic and mechanical hardware that usually governs braking and handling, and gives electronic control of each wheel at almost all times. The result, according to the reviewer, is an almost complete absence of the lag normally expected in both acceleration and deceleration.

The reviewer, who has spent close to three decades testing cars, says he has not driven anything quite like it. Comparisons with other electric performance machines make the point. The Lotus Evija also has four electric motors and can vector torque intelligently under acceleration, but Lotus deliberately avoids regenerative braking in order to preserve authentic brake feel. The Rimac Nevera, and the mechanically identical Pininfarina Battista, do use regenerative braking, but only up to around 300kW, or roughly 0.4g. The Nevera's two front motors produce about 303bhp each, giving 606bhp in total.

The M3 has less overall power than these hypercars, yet its front motors are rated at 644bhp. That gives them greater capacity to act as generators under braking. Combined with the car's battery technology, the M3 can regenerate up to 540kW under braking, which the reviewer notes is around 80 per cent more than the Nevera. Because electric power is usually quoted in kilowatts, the comparison mixes horsepower for acceleration with kilowatts for braking, a convention that the reviewer acknowledges can be confusing for readers more used to bhp.

BMW says the motors can slow the car almost up to the limit of tyre adhesion. In practice, the anti-lock braking system should rarely need to intervene, and the discs do not need to move on and off the pads, since the motor-generators respond far more quickly than mechanical brakes. Torque vectoring also works both when accelerating and when slowing down, without rear steering or locking differentials. The driver's steering input is translated directly into torque at the driven wheels.

Behind this performance lies a change in how the car is engineered. Traditionally, powertrain and braking or stability control have run on separate computers, and engineers working on anti-lock braking and electronic stability control often worked apart from those developing steering and tyres. BMW now uses a single control system that oversees everything. Its teams have had to collaborate much more closely because the systems they work on are far more tightly integrated. The company also expects the arrangement to be gentler on tyres, since brakes run cooler and the tyres are less often overworked, unless the driver deliberately switches systems off.

The reviewer argues that the car can do things nothing else he has driven can match, and that only a simulated vehicle has previously reacted as quickly. He suggests that if such technology had existed 15 years ago, with cars redefined rather than compromised by electrification, there might have been less hesitation about adopting electric vehicles.

BMW's head of the M3 project, Philipp Brunn, says the car must remain the benchmark in its segment. The reviewer points out that, given it can out-brake a hypercar, the question becomes what the segment actually is. Brunn says the category was easy to define a decade ago, but that the mix of combustion, battery-electric and plug-in hybrid cars now makes it harder to pin down, and more interesting as a result.