Requiring students to lock their phones in pouches for the school day adds one to two weeks of learning a year, according to a national study released Tuesday. The research, from Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research with researchers at Dartmouth and the testing nonprofit NWEA, found that schools requiring students to store phones in pouches saw an annual boost in achievement growth of 0.01 standard deviations. The researchers equate that gain to restoring about two minutes per hour of class time.
The team followed 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools across 49 states and Washington, D.C., from the 2021-22 through 2025-26 school years. The gains are small, the researchers said, but they persist. Achievement gains began in the first year of a ban and appeared to continue three years later. The effect held across elementary, middle and high schools, and across both wealthier and poorer schools.
The study arrives at a time when the stakes for American schools are high. Tom Kane, an economist and education professor who directs Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, released an Education Scorecard that traces a “learning recession” back to 2013, years before the pandemic. Between 2013 and 2024, eighth-grade math and reading achievement fell by roughly one grade equivalent. That slide lines up with the spread of smartphones. In 2011, fewer than a quarter of teenage students had access to smartphones; by 2018, 95 percent did.
“Strict cell phone bans seem to plug about half of that leak,” Kane said in a statement. Asked by Fortune about the rest, he pointed to two main suspects: declining test-based accountability after the No Child Left Behind Act was replaced, and out-of-school social media use. He said one major question the study did not answer is the sharp drop among the lowest-achieving students, and that the loss of test-based accountability and out-of-school social media use could be most costly for them.
The findings are contested. A National Bureau of Economic Research study released in May found that strict bans had close to zero effect on test scores. That team did find statistically significant gains with Yondr pouches in high school math, but those gains were offset by ban-related learning losses in middle school. Tom Dee, a Stanford professor and co-author of that study, told NPR he considers the early results on phone bans “largely disappointing.” Neither study has yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal.
The two studies also measured different things. The NBER work pooled school-level mean test scores at several thousand Yondr-adopting schools, while the Harvard study used student-level scores at 844 schools that use both Yondr pouches and NWEA-administered tests. Kane said the Harvard study, which is not a randomized trial, compared achievement growth at roughly 800 Yondr-adopting schools before and after adoption with that of 3,800 matched comparison schools over the same period. He said the two groups followed similar trends in the years before adoption, which made the team more confident in the result.
The Harvard researchers also flagged their own limits. They found signs that state-mandated bans in 22 states raised reading and math scores last year, but cautioned that those findings could be confounded by pre-existing trends in the states that adopted bans. Kane said a better test would compare schools that already had strict bans with schools in the same state that adopted them only after a state law passed.
The cost is modest by Kane's account. New York and 16 other states put bell-to-bell bans in place last school year, and he puts the price of a pouch at about $25 per student. “$25 is a small price to pay for an additional 1-2 weeks of instruction per student,” he said.
Advocates say the results match what schools have already observed. Ashwin Verghese, communications director at the children's advocacy nonprofit Fairplay, said anecdotal evidence showed schools making the transition could change their culture and bring face-to-face interaction back to classrooms and common areas such as cafeterias, and that the Harvard study backs this with evidence of steady educational gains. Julie Scelfo, founder and executive director of Mothers Against Media Addiction, said education is sequential, so a week or two adds up across a child's K-12 years. She said the benefit also includes the ability to focus and develop executive functioning skills. Scelfo acknowledged the study says little about phone and social media use after school, and said parents should delay access to these products until safeguards are in place.