Wireva

Geist warns Liberals' lawful access bill faces constitutional challenge

A University of Ottawa law professor told a Senate committee that the metadata retention provisions in the Liberal government's lawful access bill may be unconstitutional and lack evidence of necessity.

Zelensky: verkiezingen in oorlogstijd zouden Oekraïne versplinteren
Zelensky: verkiezingen in oorlogstijd zouden Oekraïne versplinteren
Wartime Elections Act · Wikimedia — licence per file · rights

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

A University of Ottawa law professor has told a Senate committee that the metadata provisions in the Liberal government's lawful access bill may be unconstitutional, raising the prospect of a court challenge if the legislation is passed in its current form. Michael Geist said there is little evidence that the retention rule is necessary to achieve the bill's goals.

The bill is designed to ease online investigations by police and Canada's spy agencies. A central element requires service providers to retain metadata, which refers to the traces of communication rather than the content of messages. Metadata can reveal who a person contacted, when, from where and on which devices, which is why its treatment has drawn close scrutiny from legal experts and committee members alike.

The government has already changed one part of the proposal. The original retention period was up to one year. After concerns were raised, it was shortened to up to six months. Geist's testimony, however, focused on whether the retention requirement itself is justified, not only on its length. A shorter period, in his view, does not resolve the underlying question of whether the rule is needed at all.

Geist told the committee that the metadata provision may fall foul of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the national rights document that the government says the bill respects. Ottawa has argued that the legislation is needed to prevent and investigate modern crime, which increasingly takes place through digital communications. Geist's position is that the government has not demonstrated the retention rule to be a necessary tool for that purpose, and that the justification offered so far rests more on general assertions than on specific evidence.

The concerns arrive as the bill moves through the Senate, where committee members are weighing its provisions clause by clause. Because metadata shows patterns of contact and movement even without revealing what was said, critics argue that the privacy intrusion is substantial for ordinary Canadians who have no connection to any investigation. Should the metadata requirement survive in its present form, it could become the subject of litigation, a prospect Geist has flagged as a real risk to the legislation's durability.

The government maintains that the measures strike an appropriate balance between public safety and privacy protections, and it has stated that the bill upholds the Charter. Officials have pointed to the shortened retention period as evidence that the government listened to concerns raised during consultations. Whether the Senate will press for further changes, or whether the bill proceeds largely unaltered, remains to be seen as the committee continues its work.