Manchester United have made the worst start to a Premier League season in 40 years, collecting six points from their first six matches. Bruno Fernandes, named PFA Player of the Season only seven weeks earlier, has been among the most visible figures in that struggle, and the question now facing the club is whether his decline is the reason for the slump or a reflection of wider problems.
The numbers point to a sharp fall. Fernandes has scored three goals and provided one assist this season, all of them against Ipswich, the only victory United have recorded so far. Last season he was involved in 9 goals and 21 assists in the Premier League, a record he shared with Thierry Henry and Kevin De Bruyne. In the final eleven games of that campaign, he was directly involved in 12 of United's 21 goals.
His underlying statistics show a change in his role on the pitch. He is averaging 3.3 shots per game, the second-highest figure of his career, but only 0.8 of those are on target, the second-lowest rate at the club. His chances created have dropped from 4.0 per game last season to 2.5 this term, and he has created only one big chance so far, against Ipswich. Taken together, these figures suggest a player who is taking more efforts from distance and in less dangerous positions.
Fitness has also been a concern. Fernandes was left out of Portugal's squad at one point, and the national team coach said he had played through pain. He has since been cleared to return for the last two international matches, and United's manager, Michael Carrick, has said the knock is manageable and that the player is nearly fit. Carrick has also made clear that no player is guaranteed a starting place.
The wider context helps explain some of the difficulties. Casemiro left for Inter Miami this summer, removing a major presence from the midfield. Benjamin Sesko, the striker who would have offered a key partner for Fernandes, is out with a shin problem and has no confirmed return date. Last season Fernandes set up four of Sesko's nine league goals in 2026, so the striker's absence has removed one of the most productive links in his game. The club did not sign a striker during the summer, prioritising midfield instead.
Other setbacks have compounded the problem. Amad Diallo was injured before the opening match at Hull. Matheus Cunha has been deployed up front but keeps dropping into the space that Fernandes occupies, crowding the area where the captain normally operates. In the defeat to Tottenham, Fernandes took 23 minutes to complete a single pass, a moment that illustrated how far his influence has receded.
The central question remains unresolved. Fernandes's fall from his level of last season could be the principal cause of United's problems, given how much the team has depended on his creativity. Equally, it may be a symptom of a squad weakened by departures, injuries and a lack of attacking reinforcement. United face Atlético Madrid in the Champions League on Tuesday, and the match will offer an early test of whether the captain can return to form and whether the team can begin to recover.