Wireva

Florida prosecutors drop charges against illegal immigrant in fatal grocery store crash

Prosecutors in Florida will not file charges against a 26-year-old Venezuelan man whose SUV killed an 82-year-old grandmother in a Panama City Beach parking lot, citing the difficulty of proving he knew his license had been canceled.

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

Prosecutors in Florida will not bring criminal charges against a man accused of backing over and killing an elderly woman in a grocery store parking lot, despite what officials described as careless and negligent conduct. Larry Basford, state attorney for Florida's Fourteenth Judicial Circuit, confirmed the decision to Fox News Digital, saying several legal factors prevented prosecutors from securing a conviction under state law.

The victim, 82-year-old Deborah Murphy, was walking back to her car on May 17 after a brief stop at a Publix in Panama City Beach. Surveillance video shows her crossing the crosswalk with a bag when she was struck by a Toyota 4Runner moving in reverse, according to court records. She was facing away from the vehicle and apparently did not see it coming. The driver, Carlos Suarez-Contreras, was a 26-year-old Venezuelan national who was in the United States illegally, arrest records show. The SUV pushed Murphy to the ground, but it did not stop, and the car continued backing up, running over her, according to an arrest affidavit submitted by the Florida Highway Patrol. Murphy died from blunt force injuries less than an hour later, her daughters said.

Suarez-Contreras was initially charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third-degree felony. He was held without bond because of his immigration status and because he was considered a potential flight risk, Florida Highway Patrol records show. Prosecutors then spent almost six months working on the case. Basford said they explored charges such as vehicular homicide and manslaughter but could not establish the culpable negligence those offenses require. Using the surveillance footage, investigators re-enacted the scene and concluded the SUV was not backing quickly enough to prove the driver acted recklessly.

The central obstacle was the status of the driver's license. Records show Suarez-Contreras held a Georgia license that had been canceled, but it became invalid only a day before the crash. The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed the cancellation but declined, citing privacy concerns, to say when it occurred or when Suarez-Contreras was notified. Under Florida law, prosecutors had to prove he knew the license was suspended, and they could not establish that knowledge. Basford also noted that a 2023 Florida law invalidating licenses issued to illegal immigrants applies to certain states such as California, Connecticut and Delaware, but not to Georgia.

A passenger in the vehicle, Luis Sanabria, told a law enforcement officer at the scene under sworn testimony that Suarez-Contreras was operating the vehicle when the crash occurred. Sanabria was found to have an expired visa, according to the incident report, and was released into the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, a spokesman for the Bay County Sheriff's Office said.

Murphy's family said they are devastated by the decision. Her daughter Amy Edge, speaking alongside her twin sister Beth Schulz, said the family feels let down by the state of Florida, which had vowed to seek justice. Edge described Murphy as being in excellent health and said she was expected to have many more years with the family. She will not attend her grandchildren's weddings or meet any more great-grandchildren, Edge said. The sisters also said Florida could have set a new precedent for cases of this kind by pursuing a trial.

Basford acknowledged the outcome is painful but said the law requires proof beyond negligence. I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent, he said, adding that not every tragedy amounts to a crime.

Same event, other desks

Story file →