Wireva

Washington proposes Ukraine cede Donbas as part of peace talks

US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner reportedly proposed that Ukraine cede the Donbas region to Russia and join NATO, a package that Western commentators have questioned as uncertain and potentially damaging to Kyiv's position.

This item was produced with AI assistance under the editorial responsibility of Haydamax OÜ.

US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner have proposed that Ukraine cede the Donbas region to Russia, according to Politico, a demand put to Ukrainian negotiators in Dublin on Friday. The same territorial concession already appears in the Trump administration's 28-point peace plan, and commentators in several Western capitals are now questioning whether Washington's approach can deliver a settlement that Kyiv and its European partners can accept.

The analysis, published by Le Point and relayed in Romanian by Rador and G4Media, singles out a second element of the package as new and highly uncertain: a proposal that Ukraine join NATO. Accession to the alliance requires the unanimous approval of all 32 members, a threshold that makes any such commitment difficult to predict. The proposal is also at odds with a long-standing position of the Kremlin. Vladimir Putin has repeatedly described NATO membership for Ukraine as a red line.

Former US ambassador to Ukraine William Taylor has publicly argued that Washington should not make this proposal. His objection reflects a wider unease among analysts that the American package asks Ukraine to give up territory it has not lost on the battlefield, while offering security guarantees whose terms remain unclear.

The latest round of talks in Abu Dhabi did little to narrow the gap. According to the Wall Street Journal, the Kremlin's war aims have not changed. Russian negotiator Vladimir Medinsky has said that all of the stated goals of the war will be met. European officials were largely sidelined at the Abu Dhabi meeting, and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov mocked their wait in a hotel while the talks took place without them.

The exclusion has exposed divisions within Europe over the format of negotiations. Officials from the E3 countries, Britain, France and Germany, have been pressing for a stronger role, while officials from the European Union have pursued a separate track. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk has announced an E5 format that would include Italy and Poland alongside the three large European powers, an attempt to give the continent a more unified voice.

Reported Russian demands go further than territory and alliance membership. According to the notes compiled from the reporting, Moscow's proposal calls for NATO to withdraw from the Baltic states and return to its 1997 military posture. Finland's defence minister has ruled out his country leaving NATO and said Finland is not part of the negotiations. A Polish commentator has warned that US troop numbers in Poland could fall from 10,000 to 6,000, a change that would affect the alliance's eastern flank.

The analysis also weighs the military position on the ground. Russian losses are estimated at close to one million, and Ukrainian strikes have reduced Russia's refining capacity. Ukraine is reported to be willing to compromise but resists ceding Donbas areas that its forces still hold. The Trump administration is said to want a deal before a shift in Congress in January could constrain its policy, a timetable that adds pressure to the talks.

Whether Putin will accept any settlement linked to NATO remains uncertain, according to the analysis, and the outcome depends largely on his decision. For now, the proposals on the table leave Ukraine, its European partners and the alliance itself facing questions that the negotiations have not yet answered.