Wireva

Officials insist nationwide tech outages were not cyberattacks, experts question

Federal officials say a string of high-profile outages hitting air travel, banks and Microsoft were routine maintenance failures rather than attacks, but a cybersecurity expert warns that such quick reassurances are premature.

Federal officials moved quickly to assure the public that a string of high-profile disruptions across American life was not the result of malicious activity. Over the past week, a nationwide ground stop halted air travel, customers of JPMorgan Chase and other lenders faced banking outages, and Microsoft experienced a service disruption. Officials maintain that the failures reflect technical problems rather than a coordinated attack, but some outside experts argue that the speed of those assurances deserves scrutiny.

During the ground stop, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said the homeland and the banking system remained secure, insisting the disruptions showed no signs of a cyberattack or malicious activity. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton stated that officials saw no evidence of a coordinated or state-sponsored attack, pointing instead to routine patching and system upgrades. Clayton told the House Homeland Security Committee on Wednesday that the outages were separate service interruptions associated with maintenance and technical changes. "They are not a coordinated or state-sponsored attack," he said.

Major companies, including Microsoft and JPMorgan Chase, have also attributed their disruptions to internal technical issues or software bugs rather than intrusions. Much of the official explanation for the November disruptions centers on software updates and system upgrades. Organizations often schedule maintenance and can experience downtime when rolling out changes at scale, particularly when teams move quickly.

Danny Cooper, chief executive of critical infrastructure security firm SMET, said the speed with which the assurances were issued is itself a concern. "A blanket statement like 'there's no malicious activity associated with any of the outages' is almost impossible from a probability perspective," Cooper told Fox News Digital. He said public skepticism is understandable given how many critical systems stumbled within a five-to-six-day window. "How plausible is it that all these pillars or whatever all suffered major independent technical failures within a five- or six-day window?" Cooper asked. "I think highly improbable."

Cooper argued that ruling out foul play before investigations are complete skips essential steps. In cyber incidents, she said, that means forensic analysis and a full audit of what transpired, which take time to carry out properly. Ruling out malicious activity too early could also undermine efforts to fix vulnerabilities and prevent future incidents. An instant "nothing to see here" message can deepen public suspicion, she added, particularly when several institutions echo the same conclusion before audits are finished.

The debate has also taken on a political dimension. The Democratic National Committee criticized the administration for offering conflicting explanations. In a statement, DNC Deputy Communications Director Kendall Witmer said the administration had repeatedly offered conflicting statements about the causes of the outages. She pointed to remarks in which Mullin suggested artificial intelligence was responsible for the outages, and to later comments by Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who contradicted Mullin and would not attribute the outages to AI.

Cooper also warned that scheduled upgrades create windows that sophisticated adversaries may watch closely. If companies roll out updates en masse, she said, a higher number of outages becomes more likely, but it is also possible that attackers could use those moments to inject malware or exploit weaknesses. For now, officials have said investigators are examining routers and that there are no signs of a foreign cyberattack, while the full causes of the disruptions remain to be confirmed through further review.

Same event, other desks

Story file →